Substack defined the modern paid newsletter business. The platform took roughly 10% of subscription revenue plus Stripe processing, handled hosting and email delivery, and gave individual writers infrastructure that previously required either a tech team or a full-time newsletter SaaS subscription. The deal looked reasonable when there was no real alternative.
Over the past three years, the alternatives have multiplied. Beehiiv, ConvertKit, Ghost, Mailchimp, and a half-dozen others have built specifically to compete with Substack on different parts of the newsletter creator's stack. Each has tradeoffs — fee structure, feature depth, audience-portability, country availability, hosting model. The Substack 10% is no longer the only game in town. The question every newsletter writer with a paid subscriber base is now asking is which platform actually keeps the most of the subscriber dollar in the writer's pocket.
What each newsletter platform actually costs
Substack. 10% platform fee plus Stripe processing (approximately 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction). Effective rate for a paid subscription approaches 13%. The platform handles hosting, email delivery, recommendations, the Substack app discovery layer, and the integrated comments and chat features. No monthly fee.
Beehiiv. 0% on subscription revenue. The platform monetises through ad placements within the newsletter (the Boosts marketplace) and through paid plans for premium features. A writer keeps the full subscription revenue but accepts integrated ads as part of the platform's economic model.
ConvertKit. Flat-fee subscription tiers based on subscriber count ($9-$29-$59+ monthly depending on list size and features). 0% on subscription revenue but pays Stripe processing on transactions. Best for writers with significant lists who want predictable monthly costs rather than percentage cuts.
Ghost (self-hosted or Ghost Pro). 0% on subscription revenue. Self-hosted requires server setup; Ghost Pro is a hosted version with monthly fees ($9-$199 depending on subscriber count and features). Stripe processing applies. Best for writers with technical comfort who want full control.
Mailchimp. Tiered monthly pricing based on contact count plus paid newsletter features. Less focused on the paid-creator model than the others; better for newsletters tied to other businesses than for standalone newsletter careers.
The pattern: Substack remains the easiest entry but the most expensive at scale. Beehiiv removes the percentage but introduces ads. ConvertKit and Ghost remove both but require either monthly fees or technical setup. Every choice is a tradeoff on a single dimension; none of them gives the writer 0% on subscription revenue without a separate cost layer.
What newsletter writers actually complain about
"Substack's 10% adds up to thousands a year." A writer with 1,000 paid subscribers at $5/month grosses $60,000 annually. The 10% Substack cut is $6,000. Add Stripe and the figure climbs further. Writers with growing lists notice the percentage cut rising in absolute terms even when their subscription rates stay constant.
"Beehiiv's ads change the relationship with subscribers." The newsletter that the subscriber paid for now contains placed advertisements selected by Beehiiv's marketplace algorithm. Some writers like the income split this provides; others find the change in subscriber-experience uncomfortable.
"Ghost requires me to manage infrastructure I didn't sign up to manage." Self-hosted Ghost is technically capable but operationally demanding. Writers who switched for the 0% rate often migrate back to a hosted platform after the first server outage.
"Migrating subscribers between platforms is harder than it should be." Subscriber lists are exportable but recurring payment relationships often are not — meaning a writer who switches platforms has to re-acquire the payment relationship even when the email relationship transfers.
Join the conversation.
0 comments · Be respectful, be specific, be useful.
Be the first to comment.